Table 33 supports the investigation of item bias, Differential Group Functioning (DGF), i.e., interactions between classes of items and types of persons. Specify DIF= for person classifying indicators in person labels, and DPF= for item classifying indicators in the item labels.
Example output:
You want to examine item bias (DIF) between Females and Males in Exam1.txt. You need a column in your Winsteps person label that has two (or more) demographic codes, say "F" for female and "M" for male (or "0" and "1" if you like dummy variables) in column 9.
Table 33.1 is best for pairwise comparisons, e.g., Females vs. Males. Use Table 33.1 if you have two classes of persons, and Table 33.2 if you have two classes of items.
Table 33.3 or Table 33.4 are best for multiple comparisons, e.g., regions against the national average. Table 33.3 sorts by item class then person class. Table 33.4 sorts by person class then item class.
Table 33.3
DGF CLASS-LEVEL BIAS/INTERACTIONS FOR DIF=@GENDER AND DPF=$S1W1
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| PERSON OBSERVATIONS BASELINE DGF DGF DGF DGF ITEM |
| CLASS COUNT AVERAGE EXPECT SCORE SIZE S.E. t Prob. CLASS |
|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| F 234 .46 .46 .00 .06 .28 -.22 .8294 1 |
| F 54 .85 .84 .01 -.18 .50 .36 .7224 2 |
| F 18 .89 .85 .04 -.50 .83 .60 .5541 3 |
| F 18 .00 .01 -.01 .00< 3.00 .00 1.000 4 |
| M 221 .51 .50 .01 -.16 .27 .59 .5552 1 |
| M 51 .86 .86 .00 .00 .61 .00 1.000 2 |
| M 17 .82 .87 -.04 .76 1.04 -.74 .4734 3 |
| M 17 .00 .01 -.01 .00< 2.40 .00 1.000 4 |
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 33.4
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| ITEM OBSERVATIONS BASELINE DGF DGF DGF DGF PERSON |
| CLASS COUNT AVERAGE EXPECT SCORE SIZE S.E. t Prob. CLASS |
|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| 1 234 .46 .46 .00 .06 .28 -.22 .8294 F |
| 1 221 .51 .50 .01 -.16 .27 .59 .5552 M |
| 2 54 .85 .84 .01 -.18 .50 .36 .7224 F |
| 2 51 .86 .86 .00 .00 .61 .00 1.000 M |
| 3 18 .89 .85 .04 -.50 .83 .60 .5541 F |
| 3 17 .82 .87 -.04 .76 1.04 -.74 .4734 M |
| 4 18 .00 .01 -.01 .00< 3.00 .00 1.000 F |
| 4 17 .00 .01 -.01 .00< 2.40 .00 1.000 M |
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This displays a list of the local difficulty/ability estimates underlying the paired DGF analysis. These can be plotted directly from the Plots menu.
DGF class specification identifies the person-label columns containing DIF classifications, with DIF= set to @GENDER using the selection rules. The item-label columns for item classes are specified by DPF=.
Table 33.3. The DGF effects are shown ordered by Person CLASS within item class.
Table 33.4. The DGF effects are shown ordered by Person CLASS within Item CLASS.
KID CLASS identifies the CLASS of persons. KID is specified with PERSON=, e.g., the first CLASS is "F"
OBSERVATIONS are what are seen in the data
COUNT is the number of observations of the classification used for DIF estimation, e.g., 18 F persons responded to TAP item 1.
AVERAGE is the average observation on the classification, e.g., 0.89 is the proportion-correct-value of item 4 for F persons.
COUNT * AVERAGE = total score of person class on the item
BASELINE is the prediction without DGF
EXPECT is the expected value of the average observation when there is no DIF, e.g., 0.92 is the expected proportion-correct-value for F without DGF.
DGF: Differential Group Functioning
DGF SCORE is the difference between the observed and the expected average observations, e.g., 0.92 - 0.89= -0.03
DGF SIZE is the relative difficulty for this class, e.g., person CLASS F has a relative difficulty of .07 for item CLASS 1-. ">" (maximum score), "<" (minimum score) indicate measures corresponding to extreme scores.
DGF S.E. is the approximate standard error of the difference, e.g., 0.89 logits
DGF t is an approximate Student's t-statistic test, estimated as DGF SIZE divided by the DGF S.E. with a little less than (COUNT-2) degrees of freedom.
Prob. is the two-sided probability of Student's t. See t-statistics.
ITEM CLASS identifies the CLASS of items.
